How to Shallow the Club to Fix a Slice
What Shallowing the Club Actually Means
On the downswing, the club can do one of two things from the top: come down toward the ball above the hand line (steep) or drop below it onto a flatter plane (shallow). The first is the classic over-the-top move of the slicer: the shoulders and arms throw the club outward, and the clubhead crosses into the ball from outside to inside.
Ben Hogan already described this in Five Lessons: the downswing plane isn't the same as the backswing plane. It's flatter, and its axis points to the right of the target (for a right-hander). That plane shift in the transition is essentially what's called shallowing the club today. David Leadbetter, in The Golf Swing, describes it as dropping the club "into the slot": the arms and hands fall while the body starts to turn, instead of the shoulders yanking the club outward.
Why It Fixes the Slice: The Ball Flight Laws
TrackMan's Ball Flight Laws separate two variables at impact: clubface orientation (face angle) and clubhead direction (club path). Initial launch direction depends mostly on the face — TrackMan puts it at roughly 75% with irons and 85% with the driver — while curvature depends on the gap between face and path.
A slice is a face that's open relative to the path. A player who comes over the top has a negative (out-to-in) path, so even with the face aimed at the target, it's already open relative to that path, and the ball curves right. When you shallow the club, the path becomes more neutral or in-to-out: with the same face angle, the face-to-path gap shrinks or flips, and the curve disappears or turns into a draw.
Watch out for the flip side: if you shallow the club but the face is still wide open to the target, the ball will start right and stay right (a push or push-slice). Shallowing fixes the path; you still need to control the face, starting with your grip.
How to Do It: Sequence and Tempo
- Start the downswing with your hips. Hogan insists the hips initiate the move toward the target. If the shoulders fire first, the club almost by definition comes out and over; that's a reversed sequence in the transition.
- Let your arms drop before you turn hard. Leadbetter suggests feeling like your hands fall toward your right back pocket while your chest is still facing back for a moment.
- Don't rush the transition from the top. John Novosel, timing hundreds of tour swings on video, found a 3:1 tempo ratio between backswing and downswing (Tour Tempo). A hasty move from the top tends to fire the shoulders early and steepen the club.
- The outside-object drill. Place a headcover or towel a few inches outside and behind the ball: if you clip it, the clubhead came from outside the line. Adam Young (The Practice Manual) recommends this kind of external constraint over thinking about body positions.
Birdia uses your phone camera to analyze the phases of your swing and flags whether the shaft comes over the hand line in transition — the visual tell of an over-the-top move. Only a radar unit like TrackMan gives you the exact path in degrees, but the camera shows you whether the pattern is improving session to session.
Sources
- Ben Hogan — Five Lessons: The Modern Fundamentals of Golf.
- David Leadbetter — The Golf Swing.
- TrackMan — Ball Flight Laws.
- John Novosel — Tour Tempo.
- Adam Young — The Practice Manual.
Frequently asked questions
Does shallowing the club guarantee a draw?
No. It only changes the path; a draw shows up if the face is closed relative to that new path. According to TrackMan's ball flight laws, with an in-to-out path and a face still open to the target, the ball starts right and stays right — that's a push. Shallowing and face control go hand in hand.
Can you shallow the club too much?
Yes. If the club drops too far below plane and the body stops turning, the clubhead comes too far from the inside, and you'll see hooks, pushes, and fat shots. The goal isn't the flattest possible plane — it's simply getting the path off that outside-in line, the way Hogan describes the downswing plane.
Why do I come over the top if my backswing is on plane?
Because coming over the top almost always starts in the transition, not the backswing. If the shoulders start the downswing before the hips, or if you snap the club down from the top and break the 3:1 tempo Novosel measured, the club comes out and over even with a perfectly good backswing. Work on the order: hips first, arms drop, then turn.
Analyze your swing free with Birdia →